ObservabilityXVII · Recording RulesRecordingRules
Rule Evaluation
What you'll learn
- Explain rule evaluation in production terms
- Configure and operate rule evaluation in a production observability stack
- Recognise and diagnose the most common failure modes
- Apply the discipline to a real Prometheus / Grafana / Loki / Tempo environment
Prerequisites
Verified against Prometheus 2.55.x · Alertmanager 0.28.x · node_exporter 1.8.x · blackbox_exporter 0.26.x · Grafana 11.x · Loki 3.x · Tempo current · OpenTelemetry Collector 0.110.x · Grafana Alloy current · Docker Engine 28.x · Ubuntu 24.04 LTS · Debian 12 (Bookworm) · RHEL / Rocky / AlmaLinux 9.x · 2026-08-13
Rules evaluate at a fixed interval, default 1m. The evaluation_interval is global. Each group of rules is evaluated together.
A rule that fails (e.g. the underlying metric is absent) produces no series for that evaluation; the rule does not raise an error. The absence is the symptom.
A missing series can mean the rule is wrong, the source data is wrong, or the source is not yet scraped. The platform returns no value to the dashboard; the operator must investigate.
What it is
A precise definition of rule evaluation, scoped to production operations.
Why a sysadmin cares
Production framing. The operational pain this concept addresses, or the incident class it prevents.
How it works
The mental model.
How to configure it
# Configuration snippet illustrating the lesson topic
example_setting: value
How to validate it
promtool check config /etc/prometheus/prometheus.yml
How it can fail
The high-frequency failure modes:
- Silent misconfiguration.
- Crash on load.
- Performance regression.
- Permissions failure.
- Schema / version drift.
How to troubleshoot it
The diagnostic order:
- Was it working before?
- What does the service’s view say?
- What does the platform’s view say?
- Form hypothesis, find evidence, test, validate.
Security implications
Rule Evaluation has security implications wherever the relevant component exposes an HTTP endpoint, an authentication layer, or a credential.
Performance implications
Performance implications come from cardinality, scrape / push interval, rule size, retention, and query cost.
Production guidance
- Validate before applying.
- Test changes in a non-production environment.
- Document operational defaults in the team’s instrumentation guide.
Verification
You should now be able to answer:
- What is rule evaluation in production terms?
- Why does a sysadmin care about it?
- How does it fail and how do you diagnose the failure?
Quiz
Knowledge check · 8 questions
Q1. What is the primary purpose of rule evaluation?
Q2. Which failure mode of rule evaluation is most operationally costly?
Q3. Production verification should run on production hosts.
Q4. First response when rule evaluation misbehaves?
Q5. Name one signal that confirms rule evaluation is healthy.
Q6. Which of these are validation steps?
Q7. Right discipline when changing in production?
Q8. Telemetry usefulness requires:
Passing score: 75%. Answers are checked in this browser.